'I am awaiting the day most people owning the HDSLRs start shooting something worth looking at.' -VK
True. Very True. Content.. I just got a gh1, so i'm seeing what it can do. As far as film modes go, it is paramount that you use different ones for different situations. I have found that the approach that emphasizes taking the sharpness down to -2 no matter the situation is not a very good one. dynamic range is an analogous concern: in darker situations it becomes important if it isn't lit very well (although stopping down with decent lighting makes it somewhat less important)... I have found that dynamic mode bleeds the color a bit while adding contrast. nostalgic is seemingly the most flat and brightest of them all and has a fairly bland color response (it's a step past smooth in all these ways), standard is fairly self explanatory, nature seems to have better contrast than smooth and nostalgic and also has a balanced color response.
In using smooth with -2 sharpness for a while, as many testers have recommended as a must, I have found it negates the purpose of getting the sharpest lenses around because of the inherent limits of the format-mainly in comparison to medium and large format cameras, which are much less worried with sharpness due to the effective area of exposure (size of the picture). Also it may well be making the processor work harder with digital filtering and the like, by altering sharpness in film modes... So leaving the sharpness alone instantly cured a concern with clarity that i had using smooth or nostalgic modes.
I think it's a worthy topic to test at length the characteristics of the film modes because just in an hour or so I found that it significantly alters the characteristics of the image to the point of even a 1/2 to full F-stop compared from nostalgic to dynamic. Of course I haven't looked at the manual regarding modes either, but I doubt it says much.
as far as the 5d goes, it does better in darker situations (just about anyone would agree) than most dslr's, the gh1 I love for its lens versatility (try using a PL lens ((usually equated with cinema lenses) on a 5d)) and also for its clarity... filmic smoothness can always be achieved with astute color correction and processing. The most film like dslr I've seen is the Nikon D90--looks like 16 or 8mm film to the T... The D90 only shoots in 720p at actual TRUE 24 frames per second, not 23.976.... which makes it perhaps the most unusual dslr video camera of the last few decades to my mind... In natural low light it has a grain that is totally unlike any other digital camera out there.... but for good old fashioned dslr video at full 1080 HD I like the gh1 (I don't like the smaller/more fragile build of the gh2 and I wasn't that into its image for some odd reason though I've seen some good things from it, to be sure).
Spend a little time to solve problems with colors on GH1. In most I don't like the Red color on it because it's almost orange. Only in RAW photos true Red colors. Simple example: Video
RAW
In the beginning i tried to fix it with Film Modes. On vectorscope they look almost same, but Vibrant -2 0 0 0 mode is little more close to RAW than others. So i took Vibrant as start point. Then i did use Channel Blend plugin in Sony Vegas to change color tones and shift them in RAW colors. Here is settings i get: First variation
Second variation, with brighter greens, and more close to RAW i think
Also you need to correct levels, after all this let's see the result: Video, did shot this with saturation +2
Video, this one i desaturated in post
RAW
@humpman, nice work. I really have given up on such a thing but you did a great job of getting there. Just goes to show that with hard work you can still dig out even more image quality from this camera.
@Aria thanks for response, i don't know how much people still seriously use GH1, but i believe they exist. Also there is new patched firmware for it http://www.personal-view.com/talks/discussion/8601/panasonic-gh1-firmware-research-testing#Item_15
@humpman, I still use my GH1 every week and have been for years shooting local TV shows and events. Nothing amazing but it does the job. I just can't use it to shoot landscapes of thick foliage in day light. It locks up the camera every time. If there's a bush swaying in the background it can put the fear of God in me. So I have other cameras like my G5's that I use for that stuff. The G5 is a pretty good camera if you use manual lenses. The GH1 has more dynamic range but the G5 can shoot with no issues in wide angle landscapes.
@humpman your findings on the film mode and Sony Vegas processing are very interesting! Is there any chance to closely replicate RAW colors using combinations of film mode and build in WB correction for GH1?
@yskunto in the beginning i tried to solve it with only Film Modes and WB correction, but results was pretty poor, i wasn't pleased by results.
It looks like you're new here. If you want to get involved, click one of these buttons!